The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (2024)

Home > Stories > With Pam > The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need

Pam Anderson| |13 Comments

The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (1)A few weeks ago USA Weekend (where I’ve been food columnist for the last eight years) ran my recipe for sweet tender muffins. Other than my weight loss feature a couple years ago I don’t think I’ve ever gotten as many questions and comments on a story. And because one reader’s question generally represents a thousand cooks, I’m re-offering the recipe here with more info.

I developed this recipe in the mid-nineties when I worked at Cook’s Illustrated. Tired of baking up inconsistent muffins, I wanted a formula that gave me consistently big, beautiful ones. After systematically testing my way down the ingredient list, the following recipe emerged.

3 cups all-purpose flour (the right amount to produce 12 big ones)
1 tablespoon baking powder (for impressive rise)
1/2 teaspoon baking soda (to neutralize some of the yogurt’s acidity)
1/2 teaspoon salt (to enhance flavor)
1 cup minus 1 tablespoon sugar (for a not overly sweet muffin)
10 tablespoons butter (for tenderness and flavor)
2 large eggs (for structure and lift)
1 1/2 cups plain low-fat yogurt (for an extra-thick batter that bakes into beautiful mushroom-capped breads without overflowing the cups)

Baked at 375, this batter made a dozen muffins with 1/2-cup capacity.

Like good wine, however, my recipe has become more interesting over time. Here’s what I’ve learned since it was first published.

•1 cup minus 1 tablespoon of sugar is a silly measurement—1 cup is perfectly fine.
•A mid-nineties food lover, I was less concerned with calories, so when someone questioned the generous lump of butter in the recipe, I retested with an even stick. I’m all about cutting fat, but here’s not the place to do it.
•As I come up with new flavor combinations, I generally figure 1 1/2 cups for single add-in (e.g. dried blueberries) but 1 cup each for 2 add-ins (chocolate chips and dried cherries)
•There’s enough batter to make 4 dozen mini muffins (baked at 450 for 12 minutes).
•Although I think quick breads are more cake-like, there’s enough batter to make 4 mini loaves (baked at 350 degrees for 45 minutes).
•Since many muffin cups are actually 1/3-cup capacity, there’s enough batter to make 18 of that size.
•A half recipe makes a pretty mean coffee cake too.

So below is a great all-purpose recipe I hope you’ll enjoy over the holidays and beyond. Over the years I’ve pretty much found it to be the only muffin I really need.

The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (2)

About Pam Anderson

Pam Anderson considers herself Every Cook. A New York Times bestselling author, she has been cooking nearly everyday for over 30 years. With seven published books, she brings satisfying recipes and sage advice to both novice and veteran cooks. Whether you’re on a quest for the perfect brownie, wanting to get dinner on the table effortlessly, hoping to entertain more simply, attempting to shed pounds permanently, or looking to eat delicious meatless, Pam can help. AARP’s official food expert, she is a chef contributor at Runner’s World magazine. Pam is former Executive Editor of Cook’s Illustrated magazine. Her food articles have appeared in many food magazines. She teaches cooking classes across the country and appears frequently on TV and radio. She currently is blogging at her new site, Copper House Events.

« Shrimp Curry with Mangos, Sweet Potatoes, and Lime

Master Recipe for Sweet Tender Muffins »

13 Comments

  1. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (3)Amber says

    Lovely. I have a ‘fruit and cream’ muffins recipe that I use interchangeably, but I love this for a more meaty muffin, if that’s a proper description.

    And say, is that last year’s Christmas present those muffins are sitting on? Either way, beautiful plate 🙂

    Reply

  2. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (4)Pam says

    Good eye, Amber. Yes, that’s that really cool platter you gave us for Christmas last year. Little did you know when you gave it to us that it’d be featured in a blog that was yet to be conceived.

    Reply

  3. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (5)susan says

    Thanks for all the explanations in parentheses! Really — it helps me understand a recipe better — and . . . if you keep sending more great recipes I’m gonna be a barrel by Jan 1!!!

    Reply

  4. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (6)Sally K says

    I love the master recipes with variations. Then I can come up with even more variations! It’s win-win-win!!

    Reply

  5. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (7)Mary Taylor says

    Hi Pam,

    We just returned from Christmas with Peter and your prime rib recipe from The Perfect Recipe took center stage. They swear by those recipes and also the ones in “For Having People Over”
    Can[t wait to see the new “One Dish” coming in the fall.!! Happy New Year! Mary

  6. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (8)Molli says

    The lemon poppyseed variation is great! How many calories are in each?

    Reply

  7. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (9)Rebecca says

    These have been a favorite at our house for many, many years. They are simply perfect! We like almond poppyseed, mocha chip, and your banana variation the best. I’m using a blog to record recipes and housekeeping information for my daughter. Is there a way I can put this recipe on that blog without infringing copyright?

    Reply

  8. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (10)Jade says

    In the oven now!!

    Reply

  9. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (11)Patricia says

    Thank you for the recipe! Could these be made into double chocolate muffins?

    Reply

    • The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (12)Pam Anderson says

      Absolutely, Patricia, and thanks for taking time to write us.

      Reply

  10. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (13)Steve Andrews says

    I’ve made this recipe twice. The first time, following verbatim, the crumb was satisfactory but the tops over-browned before the centers were done. The tops also did not open up and were stiff, not allowing the muffins to fully rise to maximum potential. Everyone did like the taste of them. The second time, after mixing the butter, sugar and eggs, I put away the mixer and attempted to fold the ingredients as you would a traditional muffin recipe. The dough was too stiff to work at these ratios so I had to add milk to loosen it up. The crust turned out far better than the first batch and had the texture and fissures that you would expect. The crumb was more airy but even then, the crumb was tight, not dense, but the holes were tiny.

    I am not a professional baker but I have baked my share of muffins. This recipe is quite tasty but again, the end result isn’t what one would expect of a muffin.

    Reply

  11. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (14)Jesus in Cali says

    Awesome! Thank you so much for sharing!!!!

    Reply

  12. The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (15)Ess Kay says

    Hello. On your page titled “The Only Muffin Recipe You might Ever Need,” you say “So below is a great all-purpose recipe . . .” Presumably that would be the one that you’ve updated with 1 cup sugar, etc. But there is no recipe “below”; only comments.

    Hope this is helpful.

    Reply

Share Your Comments & Feedback:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Only Muffin Recipe You Might Ever Need — Three Many Cooks (2024)

FAQs

What is the most important rule to follow when baking muffins? ›

The number one rule for successful muffins is: Don't over-mix the batter. Use a rubber spatula to quickly fold (gently stir) the liquid ingredients into the dry ones. A few streaks of flour still showing is okay, especially if you plan to add in extra ingredients like fruits and nuts.

What is the challenge with the muffin method? ›

The main challenge of the muffin method is mixing the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients without activating too much gluten. This is especially challenging with traditional muffins which contain relatively little sugar and fat that would help tenderize gluten.

What is the most common fault when using the muffin mixing method? ›

Overmixing the batter.

When you overmix the batter, it crushes the air bubbles and ruins the fluffy texture. → Follow this tip: To ensure a batch of light, fluffy muffins, mix the dry ingredients with the wet ingredients until just barely combined, and no more dry flour is visible.

Who made the first muffin? ›

Who Invented English Muffins? As you might expect, we have a British man to thank for the English muffin, though this tasty bakery treat was born here in the United States. In 1874, Samuel Bath Thomas emigrated from Plymouth, England, to New York and started making thinner, pre-cut crumpets while he worked in a bakery.

What is the secret to moist muffins? ›

How to Make Homemade Muffins Moist: Our Top Tips
  1. Tips to Make Homemade Muffins Moist.
  2. Keep Wet and Dry Ingredients Separately.
  3. Add All Flavorings Last.
  4. Consider Paper Liners.
  5. Don't Overfill the Muffin Cups.
  6. Check the Temperature of Your Oven.
  7. Test if Muffins Are Fully Cooked.
  8. Top Your Muffins with Flavor.
Aug 9, 2021

What is the secret to high muffins? ›

The idea here is to start the muffins in a very hot oven for just a short amount of time. This activates the baking powder and allows the muffins to shoot up in height quickly. We then turn the heat down and continue to cook for longer. This is done to avoid over-browning and overbaking.

Should you refrigerate muffin batter? ›

Refrigerating food prevents bacterial growth effectively, especially for muffins. To keep muffins fresh, refrigerate them due to their moisture and sweetness, which can attract bacteria. While the flour absorbs the moist ingredients in the batter, the starches have a greater opportunity to expand.

Why do you let muffin batter rest? ›

It will make your muffins dense. Quickbreads and muffins are hydrating batters, which means the flour absorbs the liquid over time, resulting in a very moist muffin, and improving the flavor. So let your muffin batter rest, up to 24 hours if possible.

How long can muffin batter sit before baking? ›

When making muffins, it's recommended to let the batter rest overnight in the fridge, but if you don't have time, even an hour will help, per The Kitchen Whisperer.

Should you take muffins out of pan right away? ›

Let muffins cool a few minutes in the pan (follow recipe directions), then carefully remove from pan to a wire cooling rack. If the muffins stick to the pan, carefully run a small flexible metal spatula or thin-bladed knife around the sides to loosen. Muffins which are cooled in the pan too long may become soggy.

Why are my muffins soggy in the middle? ›

The oven wasn't hot enough or the muffins weren't baked for long enough. An undercooked muffin will have a center that is too moist and it doesn't peak enough.

What do they call muffins in England? ›

English muffins are usually referred to simply as muffins in the UK; sweet American-style muffins are occasionally referred to as American muffins to differentiate.

Why are English muffins so good? ›

English muffins are particularly high in selenium, an important mineral that acts as an antioxidant and plays a key role in regulating thyroid hormone production ( 3 ). They also contain manganese, which is necessary for your metabolism, brain function, and bone health ( 4 ).

What is a fun fact about muffins? ›

Here are today's five thing to know about Muffin:

The word Muffin likely derives its name from the an Old German word Muffen, the plural of Muffe meaning a small cake, Muffins come in both savory varieties, such as corn or cheese muffins, or sweet varieties such as blueberry or banana.

What is the most important rule in baking? ›

#1 Read through the recipe

Make sure to quickly skim the recipe before you start baking to understand the general flow and key steps. You can even make notes on the recipe or highlight key points to help you along.

What is the important rule of baking? ›

Never bake without measuring your ingredients. Unlike cooking, baking is first a science, then anything else. If you start adding ingredients like baking powder and sugar without measuring, it can lead to some spectacular baking disasters.

What are the most important thing to be follow in baking? ›

Baking Basics: 5 Rules to Follow
  • Read the Recipe Through Completely. At the risk of sounding way too basic, this one deserves repetition. ...
  • Follow the Instructions Exactly. ...
  • Ensure the Ingredients Are Measured Properly. ...
  • Preheat the Oven Fully Before Baking. ...
  • Measure and Prep All The Ingredients Before Beginning.
Aug 25, 2021

What is the golden rule of baking? ›

"My golden rule for baking is make it cold and bake it hot," she said. Use Grated Butter for Flakey Crust.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Last Updated:

Views: 5362

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Birthday: 1998-02-19

Address: 64841 Delmar Isle, North Wiley, OR 74073

Phone: +17844167847676

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: LARPing, Kitesurfing, Sewing, Digital arts, Sand art, Gardening, Dance

Introduction: My name is Amb. Frankie Simonis, I am a hilarious, enchanting, energetic, cooperative, innocent, cute, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.